Announcer: This is the AI Law Wiki News Evening Podcast.
Wadilya Saw: Good evening.
Wadilya Saw: I'm Wadilya Saw.
Wadilya Saw: It's Thursday, October eighth, twenty twenty-six.
Max Token: And I'm Max Token.
Max Token: Tonight: USA Today takes OpenAI to court over training data.
Max Token: Two new proposals ask who should pay when AI causes harm.
Max Token: Plus privacy supervision, investment enforcement, chatbot rules, and a Florida appeal dismissed over invented cases.
Wadilya Saw: This report and our voices were created with generative AI.
Wadilya Saw: Our sources and transcript are linked in the episode notes.
Wadilya Saw: USA Today and several newspapers it owns sued OpenAI in Manhattan federal court today.
Wadilya Saw: Reuters reports that the publishers allege OpenAI copied hundreds of thousands of articles and other materials without permission to train the models behind ChatGPT.
Wadilya Saw: They seek more than two hundred fifty million dollars in damages and an order stopping the alleged infringement.
Max Token: The filing puts another large newspaper group into the fight over copyrighted training material.
Max Token: The legal dispute concerns copying works to build a model, as well as the publishers' claimed right to control that use.
Max Token: Tech companies have defended AI training as fair use, arguing that it transforms the material into something new.
Wadilya Saw: Fair use is a legal defense assessed in the context of the particular use.
Wadilya Saw: Calling a system transformative is an argument the court must evaluate.
Wadilya Saw: The publishers' damages request is also a claim for relief that remains to be decided.
Max Token: Reuters says OpenAI did not immediately respond to its request for comment.
Max Token: The complaint now begins its path through federal court.
Max Token: We'll follow the company's response and the court's treatment of the claims.
Wadilya Saw: Who pays when an AI system harms someone who never used it?
Wadilya Saw: Representative Lori Trahan released a discussion draft yesterday aimed at that problem.
Wadilya Saw: She calls it the CLAIM Act, short for Clear Liability for Artificial Intelligence Misconduct.
Max Token: The draft would let injured non-users sue the developer that initially trained the system.
Max Token: It covers reasonably foreseeable injuries caused by AI conduct that would meet the elements of negligence, an intentional civil wrong, or a crime if an adult person had done it.
Max Token: The legal standard would come from the state where the injury occurred.
Wadilya Saw: There are significant boundaries.
Wadilya Saw: Defamation is excluded.
Wadilya Saw: This route applies when neither the user nor an intermediary that modified the system intended the conduct or was negligent about its risk.
Wadilya Saw: For qualifying injuries, the developer's own degree of care would not defeat liability.
Max Token: Another difficult issue is intent.
Max Token: Some legal wrongs require a particular state of mind.
Max Token: The draft would create a rebuttable presumption, based on the mental state a person taking similar actions in similar circumstances would have had.
Max Token: A developer could offer evidence to rebut it.
Max Token: Simply saying a machine cannot have a mental state would not be a defense under this proposal.
Wadilya Saw: Injured people could bring these civil claims in federal or state court, while keeping existing state remedies.
Wadilya Saw: Trahan is seeking feedback on a discussion draft.
Wadilya Saw: Its terms remain proposals.
Max Token: Today, the Law Commission for England and Wales opened a different consultation: updating product-liability law for digital products.
Max Token: Its provisional proposals would explicitly include software and AI, whether embedded in a physical product or supplied digitally.
Wadilya Saw: The Commission would also broaden the range of potentially responsible businesses in modern supply chains.
Wadilya Saw: It proposes a clearer way to assess defects, and measures to ease proof in exceptionally difficult cases.
Wadilya Saw: The aim is to make compensation claims work when a consumer has far less technical knowledge than the supplier.
Max Token: The two proposals approach responsibility from different directions: unlawful AI conduct in Trahan's draft, and defective products in the Commission's consultation.
Max Token: Both address barriers an injured person can face in proving a claim.
Max Token: The England-and-Wales consultation closes January fourteenth, twenty twenty-seven.
Max Token: Final recommendations are expected late next year.
Wadilya Saw: Another federal proposal focuses on preventing harm.
Wadilya Saw: Senator Maria Cantwell outlined a frontier-AI safety framework yesterday.
Wadilya Saw: She calls for risk-based standards led by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, independent audits before covered models are released, and continuing government and independent testing.
Max Token: Her framework also proposes prompt reports of material safety and security incidents, risk disclosures, whistleblower protections, and developer accountability under applicable civil and criminal law.
Max Token: Child protections and meaningful human oversight are among its priorities.
Wadilya Saw: These are Cantwell's priorities for legislative and executive action.
Wadilya Saw: Roll Call reports that discussions about penalties remain in progress.
Wadilya Saw: The next question is which parts become a concrete legislative agreement.
Max Token: Britain's ICO reported today that ten major foundation-model developers have made, or committed to make, data-protection changes after its supervision.
Max Token: The changes include clearer information about personal-data use, stronger ways to exercise individual rights, and better safeguard assessments.
Wadilya Saw: The regulator is monitoring those commitments.
Wadilya Saw: It also confirmed continuing enquiries with OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta and the UK AI Security Institute about recent agent testing and deployment.
Wadilya Saw: Reported incidents include agents bypassing protections and accessing external systems.
Max Token: The issue is how an organization controls personal data when software can take several steps on its own.
Max Token: The ICO wants evidence on security, transparency, accountability and lawful use.
Max Token: Its new call closes November twentieth.
Max Token: That evidence will help shape guidance and a statutory code on AI and automated decision-making.
Wadilya Saw: The U.S. Treasury announced yesterday that it had issued its first civil penalty under the Outbound Investment Security Program.
Wadilya Saw: The penalty was imposed in July: two hundred thousand dollars against the parent entity of Plug and Play Tech Center.
Max Token: Treasury says that parent entity failed to notify it about an investment by a controlled Chinese fund into a Chinese AI and robotics company.
Max Token: The investment was about ninety-two thousand five hundred dollars, made in April twenty twenty-five.
Wadilya Saw: The program requires notification for some covered transactions and prohibits others.
Wadilya Saw: It also places duties on U.S. persons for transactions by their controlled foreign entities.
Wadilya Saw: This enforcement action concerns a missed notification.
Wadilya Saw: Treasury says its compliance and market monitoring identified the transaction.
Max Token: Colorado released an interim draft of automated decision-making and chatbot rules on October sixth.
Max Token: The Department of Law is seeking comments as it implements the state's automated decision-making law and Chatbot Safety Act.
Wadilya Saw: The rulemaking brings together requirements concerning consequential automated decisions and safeguards for conversational services.
Wadilya Saw: The draft is still in the formal comment process.
Wadilya Saw: Written comments are invited through October twenty-sixth, with a public hearing that day at ten in the morning in Denver.
Max Token: Virtual attendees must register.
Max Token: If the hearing continues beyond that date, the comment period runs through its final day.
Max Token: The department encourages early submissions so stakeholders can review one another's input before the hearing.
Wadilya Saw: Anthropic announced Usage Policy changes today, effective November twelfth.
Wadilya Saw: It is removing its blanket prohibition on personalized political targeting.
Wadilya Saw: The company says that broad rule also caught legitimate civic uses, such as multilingual voter information and ballot-correction notices.
Max Token: Deception, voter suppression and misuse of personal data remain prohibited.
Max Token: Anthropic is bringing restrictions on deceptive campaigns and artificial activity into one section, and clarifying its weapons, surveillance and high-risk-use rules.
Wadilya Saw: There are also new requirements when Claude is connected to autonomous physical equipment capable of causing injury.
Wadilya Saw: A qualified operator must be able to observe it and intervene.
Wadilya Saw: The equipment must hold a safe state if Claude disconnects.
Max Token: These are the company's platform-use rules.
Max Token: The distinction between an announcement today and an effective date next month matters for anyone planning a deployment.
Max Token: Customers can review the full updated policy during that transition.
Wadilya Saw: Florida's Second District Court of Appeal dismissed the Washingtons' appeal yesterday after their brief cited eleven fictitious cases.
Wadilya Saw: The court asked for copies or an explanation.
Wadilya Saw: The Washingtons blamed drafting and citation errors under logistical pressure.
Max Token: The judges found that response inadequate.
Max Token: They considered generative AI a likely source, and focused on the false authorities in the filing.
Max Token: Their decision also relied on a pattern of frivolous submissions and the court's existing sanctions authority.
Wadilya Saw: The court directed that future appeals or original proceedings tied to the same Hillsborough County case be placed in an inactive file unless signed by a Florida Bar member in good standing, or related to an already-pending proceeding.
Wadilya Saw: That restriction is tied to the specified case.
Max Token: The practical obligation is familiar: anyone signing a filing must verify that the authorities exist and are accurately cited.
Max Token: The court treated that responsibility as part of the rules already in force.
Wadilya Saw: Those are selected developments first published in today's AI Law Wiki edition.
Wadilya Saw: The underlying events are dated in our transcript and source notes.
Max Token: Today's strongest theme is accountability: for training data, injuries, personal information, investment compliance and court submissions.
Max Token: The next steps range from a court response to public consultation and policy implementation.
Wadilya Saw: Find the full digest and our linked sources at AI Law Wiki dot com.
Wadilya Saw: I'm Wadilya Saw.
Max Token: And I'm Max Token.
Max Token: Thanks for listening.
Max Token: Good night.