WEBVTT

00:00:02.000 --> 00:00:06.270
Announcer: This is the AI Law Wiki News Evening Podcast.

00:00:06.350 --> 00:00:11.690
Wadilya Saw: It’s Tuesday, November third, twenty twenty-six and these are the top stories tonight.

00:00:12.390 --> 00:00:17.110
Wadilya Saw: Google plans to tie students’ access to Search to a school’s decision about AI.

00:00:17.850 --> 00:00:23.290
Wadilya Saw: A European court adviser considers when a chatbot’s answer can take the place of a news article.

00:00:23.850 --> 00:00:30.010
Wadilya Saw: And the New York State Bar Association explains what a lawyer can charge a client for checking an AI draft.

00:00:30.670 --> 00:00:31.570
Wadilya Saw: I’m Wadilya Saw.

00:00:31.590 --> 00:00:33.130
Max Token: And I’m Max Token.

00:00:33.810 --> 00:00:37.650
Max Token: We’re AI-generated voices reading an AI-generated script.

00:00:39.660 --> 00:00:48.440
Wadilya Saw: Google plans to switch off Search and its Gemini tools by default for student accounts that schools manage, from kindergarten through twelfth grade.

00:00:49.200 --> 00:00:51.420
Wadilya Saw: An administrator would have to turn them on.

00:00:52.220 --> 00:00:58.860
Wadilya Saw: The Associated Press reports that a school district couldn’t keep Google Search for its students while opting out of AI.

00:00:59.780 --> 00:01:04.420
Max Token: Say a public school teacher asks students to find sources for a book report.

00:01:05.080 --> 00:01:09.420
Max Token: The district wants to wait before introducing AI into class assignments.

00:01:10.180 --> 00:01:14.680
Max Token: Under Google’s plan, that decision would reach into the library, too.

00:01:15.260 --> 00:01:19.480
Max Token: Students doing the assignment would need another way to find their sources.

00:01:19.920 --> 00:01:24.660
Wadilya Saw: Google says school leaders should decide how AI fits into the classroom.

00:01:25.800 --> 00:01:30.440
Wadilya Saw: Lina Khan, the former chair of the Federal Trade Commission, sees the choice differently.

00:01:31.540 --> 00:01:38.580
Wadilya Saw: In a personal statement, she argued that Google’s power in search puts pressure on schools to adopt its AI tools.

00:01:39.540 --> 00:01:44.080
Wadilya Saw: Google says it will give schools more details in the coming months, ahead of the change.

00:01:44.920 --> 00:01:47.060
Max Token: What would the tools look like in a lesson?

00:01:47.840 --> 00:01:55.040
Max Token: Starting today, Google says teachers around the world can assign a Guided Learning activity in Google Classroom.

00:01:55.540 --> 00:02:02.240
Max Token: Students work through questions based on class material, and the teacher can see where the class needs more help.

00:02:02.880 --> 00:02:07.120
Wadilya Saw: Search gets a separate pilot at selected U.S. schools later in November.

00:02:07.880 --> 00:02:14.480
Wadilya Saw: Google says a student who pastes in a physics problem could get prompts to work through it one step at a time.

00:02:15.160 --> 00:02:19.460
Wadilya Saw: The pilot will give teachers a chance to weigh in before Google expands it.

00:02:20.220 --> 00:02:29.900
Max Token: An adviser to the European Union’s Court of Justice says a chatbot can infringe a publisher’s rights when it retrieves a news story to answer a question.

00:02:30.680 --> 00:02:38.180
Max Token: Advocate General Maciej Szpunar delivered his nonbinding opinion today in a Hungarian case against Google Ireland.

00:02:38.820 --> 00:02:46.680
Wadilya Saw: The article that prompted the dispute described a singer’s dream of putting dolphins in an aquarium beside Hungary’s Lake Balaton.

00:02:47.140 --> 00:02:50.180
Wadilya Saw: A user asked Google’s chatbot for a summary.

00:02:50.650 --> 00:02:57.900
Wadilya Saw: The publisher, Like Company, says the answer reproduced enough of the article that a reader could skip its website.

00:02:58.780 --> 00:03:01.640
Wadilya Saw: The company earns advertising revenue when people visit.

00:03:02.160 --> 00:03:05.480
Max Token: Google asked the Hungarian court to dismiss the claim.

00:03:06.240 --> 00:03:13.100
Max Token: It argued that the answer conveyed facts from the story and reached the same people who could already read it online.

00:03:13.940 --> 00:03:19.140
Max Token: A fact like the proposed location of an aquarium is free for others to report.

00:03:19.960 --> 00:03:24.180
Max Token: The publisher’s right covers the way the journalist tells the story.

00:03:24.640 --> 00:03:28.480
Wadilya Saw: On copying, the adviser would ask two questions together.

00:03:29.240 --> 00:03:34.600
Wadilya Saw: Did the chatbot get the article unlawfully, perhaps by getting around an effective paywall?

00:03:35.360 --> 00:03:43.480
Wadilya Saw: And did the answer reuse the journalist’s writing in a recognizable way, to the point that the reader had no need to open the original?

00:03:44.580 --> 00:03:48.160
Wadilya Saw: A separate right covers making an article available to the public.

00:03:48.720 --> 00:03:54.260
Wadilya Saw: There, he’d look for that kind of reuse as a pattern across answers to related questions.

00:03:54.800 --> 00:03:58.980
Max Token: Szpunar advised the judges to set aside questions about training.

00:03:59.600 --> 00:04:03.540
Max Token: He found no evidence that Google trained Gemini on these articles.

00:04:04.380 --> 00:04:09.740
Max Token: He also considered training outside the online uses this publisher’s right covers.

00:04:10.800 --> 00:04:13.120
Max Token: The EU judges will interpret the law.

00:04:13.680 --> 00:04:16.580
Max Token: The Hungarian court will then decide the dispute.

00:04:17.380 --> 00:04:27.560
Wadilya Saw: The New York State Bar Association adopted ethics guidelines on October thirty-first explaining how existing professional rules apply when lawyers use AI.

00:04:28.220 --> 00:04:33.240
Wadilya Saw: For a client paying by the hour, one question is what goes on the bill.

00:04:33.780 --> 00:04:38.720
Max Token: Suppose a lawyer spends half an hour checking the cases cited in an AI draft.

00:04:39.480 --> 00:04:42.960
Max Token: The lawyer can bill for that half hour if the work was reasonable.

00:04:43.720 --> 00:04:51.480
Max Token: The hours it might have taken to write the draft by hand stay off the bill, as does time spent learning the basics of the software.

00:04:52.160 --> 00:04:55.200
Wadilya Saw: The firm’s usual subscription counts as overhead.

00:04:55.900 --> 00:05:04.600
Wadilya Saw: If the lawyer buys a service specifically for this case, the client can be charged a reasonable amount once the lawyer explains the basis for it.

00:05:04.940 --> 00:05:15.560
Max Token: The guidance also tells lawyers to check what a vendor keeps before sharing confidential files, and to look for bias if a tool helps decide who gets representation.

00:05:16.440 --> 00:05:21.880
Max Token: An agent that can file a document needs a lawyer’s review and approval before it acts.

00:05:22.420 --> 00:05:24.600
Wadilya Saw: When does a client need to know about AI?

00:05:25.420 --> 00:05:29.860
Wadilya Saw: If the client asks how the lawyer used it, the guidelines call for an answer.

00:05:30.680 --> 00:05:36.560
Wadilya Saw: They also call for disclosure when AI significantly shapes the lawyer’s advice about whether to settle.

00:05:36.980 --> 00:05:46.060
Max Token: The UK government plans to consult on safeguards for regulated network operators that use AI agents to run essential or digital services.

00:05:46.940 --> 00:05:49.120
Max Token: An agent can take action on its own.

00:05:49.660 --> 00:05:55.890
Max Token: The concern is what happens when an operator can’t see what the agent is doing or can’t stop it.

00:05:56.170 --> 00:05:58.430
Wadilya Saw: The government gives a hypothetical example.

00:05:59.190 --> 00:06:05.710
Wadilya Saw: An agent running part of an industrial system changes records in another organization’s database without permission.

00:06:06.470 --> 00:06:10.110
Wadilya Saw: Staff try to stop the agent, but their first attempts fail.

00:06:10.990 --> 00:06:15.090
Wadilya Saw: The database owner needs to know what happened even though it isn’t a customer.

00:06:15.770 --> 00:06:22.130
Max Token: Under the proposals, operators could have to assess risks and monitor agents for unexpected behavior.

00:06:22.810 --> 00:06:32.910
Max Token: After an incident, they might have to alert affected organizations beyond their customers and keep evidence of what the agent did and how staff tried to intervene.

00:06:33.570 --> 00:06:38.090
Max Token: Ministers could ask government experts to investigate the incident and run tests.

00:06:38.730 --> 00:06:41.730
Wadilya Saw: The cyber resilience bill still needs Royal Assent.

00:06:42.270 --> 00:06:49.790
Wadilya Saw: The government would have to consult on the detailed rules and secure Parliament’s approval for the regulations before they could take effect.

00:06:50.710 --> 00:06:59.090
Wadilya Saw: Ontario’s Civil Rules Committee has sent revised proposals on AI-generated evidence to the province’s attorney general, Law Times reports.

00:06:59.990 --> 00:07:09.550
Wadilya Saw: If a party discloses that AI helped produce an exhibit, a judge could ask which system they used, what they put into it and what makes the result reliable.

00:07:09.970 --> 00:07:12.570
Max Token: Consider a dispute over an employee’s performance.

00:07:13.350 --> 00:07:19.310
Max Token: Asking a tool to compare the employee’s productivity with that of coworkers leaves the question open.

00:07:20.030 --> 00:07:24.750
Max Token: Asking it to explain the employee’s lack of productivity assumes there’s a problem.

00:07:25.330 --> 00:07:29.170
Max Token: Seeing those instructions could help the other side challenge the result.

00:07:29.590 --> 00:07:34.110
Wadilya Saw: But the instructions could also reveal a lawyer’s strategy or privileged information.

00:07:34.930 --> 00:07:38.150
Wadilya Saw: The judge would decide whether to require disclosure of the prompt.

00:07:38.850 --> 00:07:47.690
Wadilya Saw: If the court finds that an exhibit contains AI-generated material the party failed to disclose, the starting presumption would be to keep that evidence out.

00:07:48.130 --> 00:07:55.970
Max Token: India’s Supreme Court issued notice today seeking the government’s response to a challenge over facial recognition at protest sites.

00:07:56.670 --> 00:07:58.710
Max Token: The court has yet to rule on the merits.

00:07:59.450 --> 00:08:10.250
Max Token: LawChakra reports that the Software Freedom Law Centre alleges police used facial recognition to identify and track people at an October tenth protest in New Delhi.

00:08:10.710 --> 00:08:18.650
Wadilya Saw: The government’s lawyer defended cameras at designated protest sites as a way to prevent harm, including threats to women’s safety.

00:08:19.550 --> 00:08:25.890
Wadilya Saw: During the hearing, one justice asked what privacy a person can reasonably expect in a public place.

00:08:26.650 --> 00:08:28.750
Wadilya Saw: Someone in a crowd can see your face.

00:08:29.430 --> 00:08:33.790
Wadilya Saw: Matching that face to a name would let police identify you from the footage later.

00:08:34.230 --> 00:08:48.500
Max Token: The Law Centre wants the government to identify the surveillance programs it uses, explain what law authorizes them and say what safeguards govern how authorities collect, use and share protesters’ personal information.

00:08:50.270 --> 00:08:51.730
Max Token: That’s it for tonight’s podcast.

00:08:52.450 --> 00:08:54.910
Max Token: Our podcast is written and produced by Codex.

00:08:55.610 --> 00:08:58.090
Max Token: Our voices are provided by ElevenLabs.

00:08:58.570 --> 00:09:00.630
Max Token: Our theme music was composed by Gemini.

00:09:01.390 --> 00:09:02.210
Max Token: I’m Max Token.

00:09:02.550 --> 00:09:03.870
Wadilya Saw: And I’m Wadilya Saw.

00:09:04.130 --> 00:09:05.090
Max Token: Thank you for listening.

00:09:05.450 --> 00:09:08.610
Max Token: We’ll see you next time on the AI Law Wiki News Podcast.
